How To Quickly Identify Comment Spam

// // February 10th 2011 // SEO

Most of the time comment spam is pretty obvious, but every now and again you want to make certain you're trashing the right comments.

Google Your Comments

The fastest way to identify comment spam is to copy the comment and search for it on Google. Make sure to use quotes around the entire comment, which tells Google to look for the query in that exact order. If you get any results on the exact comment, it's most likely comment spam.

Here's one I received a few weeks ago.

Finding Comment Spam

I've highlighted the fact that Google is returning about 26,400 results for this bit of comment spam.

Here's another I plucked off of another blog during my morning reading.

Comment Spam Example

Two things to note here. First is that this technique still works even when you reach the 32 word query limit. Second, this gem returned about 90,500 results. (Is it just me or does the 'about' sort of sound like 'allegedly' in this instance?)

Comment Spam

This sad and pathetic practice gives SEO a bad name. I sometimes think a database of comment spam should be created. Who knows maybe it already exists.

I can think of a number of ways that it could be used to help sites rid itself of this parasite. Why couldn't Google alert owners (via Google Webmaster Tools) when it identified a comment that reached a certain spam threshold? Seeing the same comment even 100 times should be more than enough, never mind the 26K and 90K examples I've provided.

What about abandoned blogs or splogs where there is an abundance of comment spam? Couldn't a comment spam database help flag these sites and remove them from the index and link graph?

Of course it's more difficult than it sounds but wouldn't it be worth it?

Postscript: Leave A Comment // Subscribe (RSS Feed)

The Next Post:
The Previous Post:

4 trackbacks/pingbacks

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention How To Quickly Identify Comment Spam -- Topsy.com on February 10, 2011
  2. Pingback: Google Should Follow NoFollow Links (Long Live Elgoog!) on February 13, 2011
  3. Trackback: Quora on February 17, 2011
  4. Pingback: Facebook Comments Hides Valuable Web Content From Google on March 16, 2011

Comments About How To Quickly Identify Comment Spam

// 1 comments so far.

  1. Gyi Tsakalakis // May 21st 2012

    A nifty idea. I’m probably a little too aggressive with comment deleting. I do a quick scan. If the name and first line doesn’t pass the smell test, it’s nuked. Admittedly, I probably trash some legit comments, of which I am not proud. But comment moderation is a true time-suck. Just too many “lazy-ass toolbags” out there…

Who Are You?

Your Email Address

Your Website

You can follow any responses to this entry via its RSS comments feed. You may also leave a trackback by clicking this link.